The BIG Star Wars Question: Dark Side or Light Side?

If you were living in the Star Wars universe, do you think you’d be a light side follower or a dark side follower? Or would you consider yourself something else, like a Mandalorian Bounty Hunter or a smuggler like Han Solo?

The Truest Darkness

It’s safe to say that when people in the Star Wars universe took the dark side path, for most of them, it was a commitment like no other. And while giving yourself over to the dark side of your nature in our society is frowned upon, in the SWU, there’s a place for people like that to prosper. Just look at Kylo Ren’s rise to power or even Darth Vader.

Via Giphy

The biggest problem with the dark side is forgiveness from others. To me, that’s not really a thing when you’ve killed and maimed and terrorised so many people. I was never a supporter of the redemption arc in the last trilogy. I needed to say that.

But we know that for a Disney movie to succeed, there has to be a way for the darkest character in the story to find a way to return to the light to make things right, right?

Somewhere In-between

There are characters that sit somewhere in between both, which is where I think Han Solo would be. While he wasn’t a true dark side follower, he was also a little on the dodgy side doing shady dealings with many unsavoury characters. Not exactly a light side trait. Although he ultimately did the right thing and supported Luke and the Rebellion, he still had a little more grey leaning towards the dark.

It’s in the areas in-between where I think we, as people, have the hardest time accepting someone’s actions, even if they seem “good”. Paint a person black and they’ll always be bad until they somehow step into the light. Then everything is wonderful in the world, and we have no judgement. And that annoys me as a reader, a film-lover and a fan of popular culture.

The Light Shines the Way to Boredom!

Being a light side follower is obviously an easier choice to make because it means you will always be forgiven, even when you do terrible things. There is always forgiveness when you’re (mostly) considered squeaky-clean and always doing the right thing.

But isn’t that just a tad boring? What is a light side, goody-two shoes person without the temptation of doing something wrong? Is it easier to be someone who is good that sometimes does awful things? Or to be a bad person who sometimes acts out of character so you can feel sympathy towards them, even if it’s fleeting?

star wars netflix and chill GIF
Via Giphy

I guess I want to see characters that are doomed to live life in the shadows, even when their hands are reaching out for help. Sometimes, those characters don’t deserve to be anything better. And sometimes, the light side followers will always be good, judgemental of others who aren’t and just plain boring.

Let me know in the comments if you agree or disagree or anything in between! I’m keen to hear your thoughts.

As always, keep safe, keep creating and I’ll catch you in the next post!

If you like my Star Wars posts, you can check out more of them right here.

And while you’re there, why not consider following me, which you can do here.

 

 

7 thoughts on “The BIG Star Wars Question: Dark Side or Light Side?

  1. I agree that the gray characters can be the most interesting. Growing up, I read all the old Star Wars novels (that are no longer canon, lol) and some of my favorite stories were about Han. Your comments about dark side redemption are interesting. I guess I never really thought about it before, but you are right in saying that if a dark character turns good, we as the audience can sometimes be too eager to welcome them with open arms and forget all the bad things they have done. Thanks for the great post! I’ll be doing some more thinking about this subject.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank You for commenting 🙂 Glad that we agree on that topic 🙂 It is one that I’ve thought about off and on for some time. As a topic, it can probably be fleshed out a little more because there is so much to talk about regarding the dark side versus the light side. I mean it’s the very fabric that makes Star Wars what it is, really. Good versus Bad, Rebels against the Empire or The First Order, warrior against warrior – when you think of it like that, it does seem to be just like any other franchise where heroes and villains are involved. I find it a little funny how as an audience, we fall for this same routine every time and we think it’s different from everything else we’ve seen. George was smart to take a time-proven tale of heroes, villains, good and evil and wrap it up in what we know as Star Wars. Amazing really. Let me know if you have any other thoughts on the topic 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes. Star Wars could also be compared to Dune in that sense. It is a classic tale of really heroic heroes and really villainous villains. (From my understanding, there are more morally-gray areas and characters in the later books, but I have only ever read the first one.) Anyway, it is the way that the story is told and the quality of the story-telling that really makes these sagas stand out, in my opinion. Even though the bones of the stories themselves may not be new, the stories are presented in such a way that completely wraps the audience up and makes them forget everything else. That is the mark of a master story-teller, I think.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Oh yes, very nicely said 🙂 George is definitely a master story-teller. I am not quite ready to say that about JJ Abrams. And Rian Johnson is definitely getting there 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.